Posted By dwayne | November 24, 2026
A patient searches for a dermatologist at 9 PM. Your practice shows up in Google's top three. She taps through to your website, looks for a way to book, and can't find one that works without a phone call. The office is closed, so she goes back to the results and taps the next practice.
You earned that click and didn't get the appointment. This fall we audited 12 local practices, and that pattern turned up almost everywhere: strong on Google, hard to book.
How easy is it for a new patient to book with you? We check it in every free website audit →
What we checked
For each practice, a real person looked at the website and the Google listing the way a new patient would. Where does the practice rank when someone searches for its specialty? How many steps does it take to book? What does the homepage say in a Google result? Is there a privacy policy a patient can find? How do the reviews compare with the practice listed next to it?
Everything below is anonymized. No practice is named, and the numbers cover all 12.
What we found
9 of 12 ranked in Google's top 3
This is the good news. Most of these practices had already done the hard part: patients searching for their specialty see them near the top. It is also what makes the rest of this list expensive. Every extra step between the search result and the appointment wastes a click you already won.
The fix: keep doing what earned the ranking, and put your attention on what happens after the click.
11 of 12 made it hard to book online
Only one practice in 12 made booking easy. On the other 11, hard looked like a button that was easy to miss, a path with extra steps, or no way to ask for an appointment outside office hours.
What it costs you: the patient who looks at 9 PM doesn't wait until morning. She books with whoever made it simple, and you never see her in your call log.
The fix: put one obvious booking or appointment-request button on the homepage and on every provider page. Then try it yourself on a phone. Our post on "Book Online" buttons that don't book anything covers what to look for.
7 of 12 had no privacy-policy link we could find
Patients type their name, phone number and the reason for their visit into your forms. A missing privacy-policy link makes them wonder who sees that information.
What it costs you: some patients hesitate at the form and don't finish it. Others just call, which is fine, unless it's after hours.
The fix: link a plain-language privacy policy from the footer of every page, including the page with your contact or booking form. Have your own attorney or compliance advisor write or review the wording. That part isn't something to copy from another practice's site.
7 of 12 had a blank or generic homepage title
The title is the blue headline a patient sees in Google. On these sites it was blank, or it said something like "Home." That tells a patient nothing about who you are or what you treat, and Google may fill in its own wording.
What it costs you: when two practices rank side by side, the one whose headline names the specialty and town gets the tap. See our post on title tags for how to write one.
The fix: use your practice name, your specialty and your town, in plain words a patient would search for.
6 of 12 had far fewer Google reviews than the practice beside them
Patients compare. When two practices appear together on Google, they look at the review count and stars, then pick one.
What it costs you: a practice that has served patients for years can look new next to a neighbor that simply asked more often. Our posts on your Google Business Profile and Google reviews go deeper.
The fix: ask every patient while the visit is fresh, with one short text or email that links straight to your Google review page. Make it a habit, not a campaign.
Check your own site this week
- Search your specialty and your town on your phone. Note where you appear and what your headline says.
- Start at your homepage and try to book as a new patient. Count the taps. If you give up, so will they.
- Try it after hours. Can a patient request an appointment at 9 PM without calling?
- Scroll to the footer. Find your privacy-policy link, and click it to make sure it opens.
- Compare your Google listing with the practice beside you. Look at the review count and the most recent review date.
One related check worth a look while you're at it: whether your insurance information is easy to find.
The bottom line
Ranking gets a patient to your door. Booking gets her through it. In our audits, most practices had done the first and stumbled on the second, and the fixes are small. Work through the checklist above and you'll know where you stand.
Get your free website audit →
A real person will review your website and your Google listing, then email you the 3–5 fixes that matter most within 24 hours. No cost, no obligation.